Minnesota abortion lawsuit heads to federal appeals court Wednesday after dismissal

Women's Life Care Center and other plaintiffs are asking the Eighth Circuit to revive their lawsuit challenging Minnesota's abortion laws as supporters are encouraged to attend Wednesday's arguments.

Women’s Life Care Center has encouraged supporters to attend Wednesday’s hearing, urging them in an event flyer to "pack our courtroom."

A lawsuit challenging Minnesota’s abortion laws will return to court Wednesday as a federal appeals panel considers a case that was dismissed last year.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit is scheduled to hear arguments at 9 a.m. Wednesday in Women’s Life Care Center, et al. v. Keith Ellison, et al.

Filed by a group of pregnancy resource organizations and medical doctors, the original lawsuit argued that Attorney General Keith Ellison, Gov. Tim Walz, Planned Parenthood, and other groups were working “to effectuate the termination of the pregnant mother’s constitutionally protected relationship with her child whether or not such termination is voluntary.”

U.S. District Judge Nancy Brasel dismissed the lawsuit on Aug. 27, 2025, granting the defendants’ motions to dismiss and denying the plaintiffs’ request for a preliminary injunction. The plaintiffs appealed that ruling to the Eighth Circuit.

The plaintiffs’ appellate filings address several questions, including whether they have legal standing to bring the case and whether the abortion providers can be treated as state actors under federal civil rights law.

Attorney Harold Cassidy, who represents the plaintiffs, told Alpha News that the judges cannot answer those questions without also considering the constitutional rights the plaintiffs say are being violated.

“The merits issue, the rights of the mothers, is before the court, because it’s the question of the jurisdiction and the question of state action are intimately interwoven with the merits issues, the mother’s rights,” Cassidy said. “You can’t decide one without identifying the other.”

If the Eighth Circuit sides with the plaintiffs, Cassidy said the case would return to federal district court.

“They will have to remand it back to the district court,” he said.

In one of their briefs, the plaintiffs ask the Eighth Circuit to reverse and vacate the dismissal and remand the case with instructions to enter a preliminary injunction barring the defendants from performing abortions under Minnesota’s current legal framework.

Alpha News first reported on the lawsuit in June 2025 and covered a press conference announcing the case.

The plaintiffs argue that Minnesota’s abortion laws violate rights protected by the 14th Amendment by failing to provide sufficient due process and equal protection safeguards. Their central legal theory is that a pregnant woman has a constitutionally protected parental relationship with her unborn child and that abortion terminates that relationship.

They contend Minnesota should provide additional safeguards to ensure a woman’s decision to undergo an abortion constitutes a voluntary, knowing, and informed waiver of those asserted rights, drawing comparisons to protections used in adoption and other parental-rights proceedings.

The legal effort also includes sworn declarations from women who say they underwent abortions they did not want or experienced pressure surrounding their decisions, along with testimony and declarations from former abortion workers, medical professionals and pregnancy help center employees.

On a website dedicated to the case, the plaintiffs describe their effort as seeking to end coerced abortions, strengthen informed consent and protect what they argue are mothers’ constitutional rights.

Cassidy said the case is also intended to challenge what he views as a longstanding misunderstanding of women’s rights in the context of abortion.

“The whole concept that somehow they were advancing women’s rights, they were destroying women’s rights,” Cassidy told Alpha News. “A woman who was subjected to an abortion is not exercising a right. She’s waiving some of the most important rights any woman has in all of life.”

He said what he described as the “false teaching of Roe v. Wade” has “really left a massive impact on the psyche of the country.”

Women’s Life Care Center has encouraged supporters to attend Wednesday’s hearing, urging them in an event flyer to “pack our courtroom.”

“It’s really important for the public to understand these issues,” Cassidy said. “The real experience of these women have to be known.”

“It’s important, it’s an important public discussion,” he added.

Wednesday’s argument is scheduled for 9 a.m. at the federal courthouse in St. Paul.

 

Symone Harms

Symone Harms is a Media Production and Business Marketing student at Bethel University. She is actively involved in The Royals Investment Fund, The 25, theatre, and other leadership positions. She also cohosts Rooted, a podcast dedicated to being rooted in truth, growing in freedom, and prospering in life. A Minnesota native with a passion for storytelling and digital media, she aspires to a career in broadcasting as a news anchor and reporter.