O’Keefe and Higby make first court appearance in Minnesota felony case

A Hennepin County judge rejected prosecutors' request to bar the two journalists from communicating about the case as it moves forward.

James O'Keefe, Cam Higby, attorney Chris Madel, attorney Ryan Garry, and prosecutor Morgan Kunz appear before Hennepin County District Court Judge Luis Bartolomei Nov. 16, 2026. (Credit: Cedric Hohnstadt_

Journalists James O’Keefe and Cam Higby appeared in a small but packed Minneapolis courtroom Monday for the first time since Hennepin County Attorney Mary Moriarty charged them with felony identity theft and unlawful voting over an undercover investigation at Minnesota polling places.

O’Keefe and Higby appeared before Hennepin County District Court Judge Luis Bartolomei at the Public Safety Facility in downtown Minneapolis. Both men were released without having to post bail.

The appearance drew journalists, supporters and protesters to the courthouse after O’Keefe had publicly called on journalists to attend “in solidarity with the 1st Amendment.”

During the hearing, prosecutor Morgan Kunz asked Bartolomei to prohibit O’Keefe and Higby from communicating with each other about the case.

O’Keefe’s attorney, Chris Madel, objected, arguing that the two defendants and their attorneys need to communicate as they prepare their defense.

Bartolomei rejected the state’s request and allowed O’Keefe and Higby to remain in contact.

The defendants did agree to a no-contact condition involving the alleged victims in the case. Madel disagreed with characterizing them as “victims” but agreed to the no-contact condition.

Higby appeared with attorney Ryan Garry, who argued that bail was unnecessary and noted the lengths Higby had gone to in order to appear in Minnesota for Monday’s hearing.

The hearing lasted approximately 10 minutes.

Following Monday’s hearing, Madel criticized the prosecution in a statement to Alpha News.

“This prosecution is a disturbing example of what happens when someone is charged based entirely on politics,” Madel said. “James O’Keefe is an investigative journalist. He’s being prosecuted for exposing fraud. Mary Moriarty should be ashamed of herself. End of story.”

The criminal case stems from an undercover investigation O’Keefe and Higby conducted during Minnesota’s August primary election. The two visited Minneapolis polling places while examining Minnesota’s voter-vouching system.

Hennepin County prosecutors later charged both men with felony identity theft and unlawful voting, alleging they provided election judges with the names of registered voters without those voters’ knowledge or permission. Neither man is accused of actually casting a ballot.

“This is retaliation for doing journalism, plain and simple,” O’Keefe told Alpha News after the hearing.

Higby noted that the “state of Minnesota is so hesitant to prosecute actual criminals and then charges two journalists for conducting an investigation.”

“The case is going to go away. There’s no probable cause for the charges,” said Garry.

O’Keefe and Higby are scheduled to return to Hennepin County District Court Jan. 13 at 9 a.m. Garry said they don’t plan to take any plea agreements and will be filing a motion to dismiss.

 

Symone Harms

Symone Harms is a Media Production and Business Marketing student at Bethel University. She is actively involved in The Royals Investment Fund, The 25, theatre, and other leadership positions. She also cohosts Rooted, a podcast dedicated to being rooted in truth, growing in freedom, and prospering in life. A Minnesota native with a passion for storytelling and digital media, she aspires to a career in broadcasting as a news anchor and reporter.