Minnesota fathers sue state for ‘excluding religious education’ from certain tax benefits

"Minnesota can decide whether to offer educational tax benefits, but once it does, it cannot treat families differently simply because they choose to teach their children according to their religious faith," said attorney Brent Robbins.

Nathan Colestock
Nathan Colestock/Alliance Defending Freedom

Two Minnesota fathers say the state unconstitutionally excludes religious education from certain K-12 tax credits, according to a new lawsuit filed this week.

Represented by the Upper Midwest Law Center (UMLC) and Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), Nathan Colestock and Joseph Osburn filed the lawsuit Monday in Minnesota tax court.

Colestock and Osburn are Christians who believe they are called to raise and educate their children in accordance with a Biblical worldview.

“That means no subject can be taught apart from an understanding of God and His creation—not reading, arithmetic, science, or history. For them, there is no such thing as a secular subject. So, they choose Christian curricula, materials, academies, and co-ops that teach every lesson through that lens,” the lawsuit explains.

According to the lawsuit, Minnesota’s K-12 Education Subtraction and Credit offset the cost of tutoring, textbooks, instructional materials, and enrichment classes.

“Nearly every Minnesota parent can claim them. But there is a catch: the instruction cannot be religious,” the complaint says.

As such, the fathers are forced to choose between their faith and the tax benefit.

“The Constitution forbids that choice,” the lawsuit argues.

It calls this exclusion of religious instruction a violation of the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, the Minnesota Constitution’s guarantee of freedom of conscience, and the 14th Amendment’s protection of parents’ right to direct the upbringing and education of their children.

“Parents, not the government, have the right to direct how their children are raised and educated,” said ADF Senior Counsel Kate Anderson, director of the ADF Center for Parental Rights.

“Minnesota can’t offer all parents a tax break and then exclude families like the Colestocks and Osburns, who choose to educate their kids fully in line with their faith. We’re urging the court to uphold the fundamental right of Minnesota families to choose Christian education for their kids while receiving much-needed financial help from the state — aid that is available to all other families,” she continued.

UMLC said in a press release that Colestock is a Minnesota pastor and father of four who qualifies for both the Education Credit and Subtraction but has not claimed them because of the religious nature of his children’s education.

Osburn, a father of six, qualifies for the Education Subtraction but likewise has not claimed it because doing so would conflict with his beliefs, UMLC said.

“Minnesota can decide whether to offer educational tax benefits, but once it does, it cannot treat families differently simply because they choose to teach their children according to their religious faith,” said Brent Robbins, UMLC senior counsel for religious liberty. “The Constitution does not allow the state to force parents to choose between living out their beliefs and receiving a generally available public benefit.”

The lawsuit, which names Department of Revenue Commissioner Paul Marquart, asks the court to declare Minnesota’s religious exclusion unconstitutional. The Department of Revenue declined to comment.

“Parents should not receive fewer protections because they choose to educate their children according to their faith,” said Dr. Douglas P. Seaton, founder and president of UMLC. “UMLC exists to challenge government policies that cross constitutional lines and defend the fundamental freedoms of religious liberty and parental rights.”

 

Anthony Gockowski

Anthony Gockowski is Editor-in-Chief of Alpha News. He previously worked as an editor for The Minnesota Sun and Campus Reform, and wrote for the Daily Caller.