Lawsuit challenges Nicole Mitchell’s eligibility to serve on Woodbury City Council

At issue in Mitchell's case is a 2023 law that restored voting rights to felons as long as they are not incarcerated in jail or prison.

Left: Nicole Mitchell mugshot; Right: Sen. Nicole Mitchell/Minnesota Senate
Left: Nicole Mitchell mugshot; Right: Sen. Nicole Mitchell/Minnesota Senate

A group of Woodbury voters is asking a Minnesota district court to block former DFL state Sen. Nicole Mitchell from taking a seat on the Woodbury City Council. That request comes less than three weeks after Mitchell won her election to the council by just 101 votes.

Earlier this week, the Upper Midwest Law Center (UMLC) filed an election contest with the Tenth Judicial District in Minnesota that said Mitchell is not eligible to hold a seat on the Woodbury City Council due to her felony convictions and subsequent criminal sentence.

In 2025, Mitchell was found guilty of felony burglary after she broke into her stepmother’s Detroit Lakes home. Mitchell said she entered the home to perform a welfare check, but prosecutors said she was there to take items belonging to her late father.

Mitchell was also found guilty of felony possession of burglary tools.

Following her conviction, Mitchell resigned from her seat in the Minnesota Senate and served a short jail term. She is now out of jail and serving a five-year term of supervised probation that will expire in 2030.

Despite this, Mitchell ran for a seat on the Woodbury City Council earlier this year and was one of two people elected to that body. She won her election by just 101 votes out of more than 59,000 cast. As such, Mitchell is set to take office in January of next year.

However, UMLC’s lawsuit is attempting to block Mitchell from taking that seat, saying felons are ineligible to serve in elected office until their sentence is completed.

UMLC is bringing the case on behalf of four Woodbury voters. Two of those four voters are former Republican members of the Minnesota Legislature. Another is a former Republican candidate for office in Woodbury.

At issue in Mitchell’s case is a 2023 law that restored voting rights to felons as long as they are not incarcerated in jail or prison.

Because that law restored Mitchell’s right to vote when she was released from jail, and the state constitution allows eligible voters to hold office in Minnesota, Mitchell appeared eligible to serve on the Woodbury City Council.

Arguing against Mitchell’s eligibility in its lawsuit, UMLC said Mitchell has not received an order of discharge that restores her to “all civil rights and to full citizenship” and Minnesota law prohibits a person from appearing on a ballot if their civil rights have not been restored.

Further, UMLC said the 2023 law “does not restore a convicted felon to civil rights generally, nor does it purport to restore the specific right to hold elected office.”

The law firm also questioned the legality of the 2023 law, saying the state constitution only allows felons to vote if they have been restored to civil rights. Felons serving probation lack certain civil rights such as the right to privacy.

Additionally, UMLC said Mitchell’s probation requires her to check in with probation officers and submit to searches.

In turn, UMLC asked the court to try the matter within 20 days of the filing and disqualify Mitchell from serving on the Woodbury City Council.

“Minnesota statutes distinguish between the right to vote and the right to hold public office,” UMLC attorney Nicholas Nelson said in a statement. “The Legislature restored voting rights to certain individuals who are no longer incarcerated, but it did not restore every civil right before a felony sentence is discharged.”

Alpha News contacted Mitchell for this story but did not hear back. Mitchell has previously said she verified that she is eligible to hold office in Minnesota prior to her campaign for the Woodbury City Council seat.

 

Luke Sprinkel

Luke Sprinkel previously worked as a Legislative Assistant at the Minnesota House of Representatives. He grew up as a Missionary Kid (MK) living in England, Thailand, Tanzania, and the Middle East. Luke graduated from Regent University in 2018.