Steve Wenzel: Amy Klobuchar is no moderate

"Her attempts to create an image as that of a pragmatist and 'political moderate' are both misleading and deceptive," writes Steve Wenzel, who served in the Minnesota House for nearly 30 years.

Sen. Amy Klobuchar speaks during a get out the vote event in October 2020.
Sen. Amy Klobuchar speaks during a get out the vote event in October 2020. (Shutterstock)

In many news and editorial commentary articles in the Star Tribune, it is stated often that the DFL gubernatorial candidate, U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar, is a “moderate” in her philosophy and her votes on legislation. It is stated so often that it mistakenly comes across to readers as fact.

For example, the former CEO of Medtronic, Bill George, writes in his commentary in the June 15 Star Tribune, “Moderate Klobuchar would serve Minnesota well as Governor,” and stated, “As governor, she must … bring fiscal responsibility to Minnesota, just as she has done in the U.S. Senate.”

Mr. George could not be more mistaken or wrong in his analysis of Klobuchar’s Senate record, especially relating to fiscal issues. During her 20 years in the U.S. Senate, the national debt has more than quadrupled from $9 trillion in 2007 to $40 trillion today.

Several other Star Tribune writers have also routinely labeled Klobuchar as a moderate in her ideological leanings. Columnist John Rash, in his Aug. 15 commentary, referred to Klobuchar as “the moderate Minnesota senator who … cruised to the DFL nomination for governor.”

Even the respected, retired Star Tribune editor, D.J. Tice, confirmed in his commentary of Aug. 24, “Klobuchar has always packaged herself as a moderate” and states that she is now distancing herself from far-left officials such as Gov. Tim Walz and Lt. Gov. Peggy Flanagan. Tice accurately states that Klobuchar has “polished the centrist image at every turn.”

Indeed, Klobuchar has carefully created a senatorial self-image as that of a political moderate and pragmatist, all part of a strategy to win independents and swing voters and even some Republicans. If allowed to go unchecked and unchallenged, Klobuchar benefits politically in her deceptive efforts to win the governorship.

The fact is that Klobuchar’s votes in Congress have consistently been in line with American liberalism and so-called “progressive” ideology. Americans for Democratic Action (ADA), which is the nation’s oldest liberal advocacy group, has Klobuchar achieving a 100% rating in four annual voting record ratings and 90% or higher in many years.

Conservative rating groups of members of Congress likewise have given Klobuchar low ratings due to her consistent support for liberal and progressive legislation. Heritage Action and Conservative Review assign her lifetime Senate record at 0% to 2%, among the very lowest in Congress.

A 2019 ideological ranking of U.S. Senate members by GovTrack, a nonpartisan organization, ranked Klobuchar at 92nd on the group’s conservative-to-liberal scale, which placed her to the left of all but eight Democratic senators, and even to the left of Sens. Elizabeth Warren, Chuck Schumer and Tina Smith.

Klobuchar has also achieved a 100% rating from the Planned Parenthood scorecard. She has consistently voted for the spending of billions of dollars for taxpayer funding of abortions, both domestically to Planned Parenthood and to abortion facilities in foreign countries, a policy which polls show 75% of Americans oppose.

On the controversial issue of transgender surgeries, Klobuchar is clearly on the liberal ideological side.

In December of 2024, for instance, Klobuchar co-authored a major amendment to the U.S. defense bill that would have removed the prohibitions in that legislation on so-called “gender-affirming care” for transgender dependents of service members.

Finally, on the issue of gun control and gun-owner rights relating to the Second Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, Klobuchar has received a grade of “F” from the National Rifle Association.

The people of Minnesota have good reason to be wary and cautious about any aspirant for governor such as Klobuchar claiming to be a moderate in their philosophy when the facts show otherwise. I say this because both Tim Walz and Joe Biden ran as “moderates” for governor and president and then took sharp left turns when elected and governed as such. Both of these officials have left a most negative and disappointing record that has reduced people’s confidence in our democratic and governmental institutions.

The highly respected and late Senate minority Leader from the 1960s era, Republican Everett Dirksen of Illinois, said Americans should judge legislators by their votes on legislation—and not by what they say. “By their votes, ye shall know them.”

On this basis, it is clear that Sen. Klobuchar has established a liberal, left of center position during her long Senate career. Worse, her attempts to create an image as that of a pragmatist and “political moderate” are both misleading and deceptive and display a fundamental lack of integrity and character, qualities so necessary for elected officials.

Steve Wenzel, Little Falls, represented Morrison and Crow Wing Counties in the Minnesota House of Representatives from 1973-2001. He teaches political science at Central Lakes College, Brainerd.

The views and opinions expressed in this commentary are those of the author and do not represent an official position of Alpha News.

 

Steve Wenzel

Steve Wenzel is a former state representative from Little Falls who served in the Minnesota House for nearly 30 years as a Democrat.